The Bakery

We love baking; and we're pretty darn good at it. While dough is little more than flour and water, the recipe has been tweaked and changed over and over to get that perfect internal texture while keeping that outer crust with just enough "crackle".

Our NY/NJ style bagels are kettle boiled & baked throughout the day right in our shop, giving them their signature flavor, texture and taste, and a freshness that you won't find anywhere else.

HeroShot_Bagels_Array.png
Bagels

Rolleyholers bagels are made fresh daily using the traditional boil & bake method used in the better NY and NJ bagel shops. Tender, yet chewy with just the right amount of pull, a deep amber color and unmistakable bagel sheen.

Our team kettle boils and bake throughout each day to ensure that what your bagel is the freshest Rolleyholers can offer.

pretzels.jpeg
Pretzels

The first cousin to the bagel, Rolleyholers soft pretzels boast a soft chewy crust with a tender crumb that rival only those from Center City, Philadelphia. Our soft pretzels are made to order, ensuring that they are hot and perfect every time.

crumbcake_closeup.jpeg
Crumbcake

A soft cake and just enough cinnamon streusel topping pays tribute to the countless German bakeries of NYC and NJ. Rolleyholers crumbcake is a fan favorite and is baked fresh daily. Makes a great gift.

Warning: Rolleyholers crumb cake may trigger wonderful memories.

bread_rolls.jpeg
Bread & Rolls

Without additives, preservatives, or fillers, Rolleyholers breads are an all natural alternative to mass produced grocery bread. We slice it on request to ensure maximum freshness. We provide your basic sliced “daily bread” loaves, with specialties like challah, brioche, focaccia and anadama during holidays or by request.

carrot_cake.jpeg
Cakes

Unassuming yet delicious, Rolleyholers “Piece O, Cake” presents distinct taste sensations without the decorative fanfare.

 

DIY – Want to save money and decorate a cake yourself… Custom flavors, colors, sizes and shapes available on request.

chocolate_chip_cookies.jpeg
Muffins & Quick Breads

Rotating seasonal flavors and fan favorites, Rolleyholers muffins and quick breads make a great snack when you're short on time or need a quick fix.

pie.jpeg
Pies, Pastries, Puddings and Seasonal Creations

As a100% scratch bakery, our creativity is only limited by time. Most of our pastries are complex and labor intensive, so they are only offered when time allows. Check the baking schedule for pastry offerings or when Cinnamon Rolls, Banana Pudding and some of our other fan favorites are available.IF you have a request, or would like to place a special order, let us know!

chocolate_chip_cookies.jpeg
Cookies

Rolleyholers offers fresh baked cookies almost every day. Thick and chewy, you’ll find great value and superior quality in every bite.Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, Iced Spice,Oatmeal, Peanut Butter and More.

 

We’re always looking for suggestions on different flavors, so if you’ve got a favorite, let us know!

Baking Schedule